Miracles: Are They a Breach of the Laws of the Universe or the Perceptions of the Mind?! A Study in Scientific Reconciliation of Extraordinary Phenomena
Miracles: Are They a Breach of the Laws of the Universe or the Perceptions of the Mind?! A Study in Scientific Reconciliation of Extraordinary Phenomena Mohamed Mahmoud Ahmed Shaban Department of Doctrine and Philosophy, Faculty of Islamic Theology and Da'wah, Al-Azhar University, Tanta Branch, Egypt. Email: mohamedshaban.27@azhar.edu.eg Abstract: The study seeks to address philosophical questions regarding the nature of miracles: Are they violations of universal laws or merely of our mental perceptions? It also explores how to reconcile the disruption caused by miracles with the preservation of cosmic order, particularly in light of atheistic skepticism about prophetic miracles and their absence in the age of science. The study consists of an introduction, four sections, and a conclusion, covering the concept and possibility of miracles, major criticisms of their validity, a new theological interpretation, and the potential for causal explanation. It also examines the relationship between supernatural phenomena and the evolution of human civilization. The study aims to set up an inquiry to theological heritage to provide answers for challenges posed by empirical sciences. The study employs inductive, descriptive, analytical, critical, and retrieval methods. Key findings include: declaring a phenomenon as extraordinary means it exceeds our mental perception of the universe, without confirming it violates universal laws. Theological texts allow for understanding prophetic miracles as violations of mental perceptions, not of natural laws, aligning with scientific principles. While the recurrence of miracles is logically possible, it remains practically elusive. The evolution of divine manifestations through miracles aligns with humanity’s intellectual progress, reflecting God's wisdom. The study recommends further exploration of the boundaries between human perception and universal truths and utilizing Al-Azhar’s intellectual legacy to generate contemporary ideas on interpreting miracles. It also suggests designing educational curricula that integrate philosophy, science, and religion to enhance students’ critical understanding of miracles and supernatural phenomena.
At-Tahrir wa At-Tanweer: At-Tahir Ibn Ashour, Ad-Dar At-Tunisiyyah, Tunisia, 1984AD.
At-Tahqiq At-Taam fi Elm Al-Kalam: Muhammad Al-Husseini Al-Zawahiri, First Edition, Al-Nahda Egyptian Library, 1939 AD.
Tafsir Ar-Razi : Imam Fakhr Al-Din Ar-Razi, Third Edition, Dar Ihyaa At-Turath Al-Arabi – Beirut, 1420AH.
Tafsir Ar-Ragheb Al-Isfahani: 1st Edition, Faculty of Arts - Tanta University,
Tafsir Al-Manar: Sheikh Muhammad Abdo, and Sheikh Muhammad Rashid Reda, Egyptian General Book Organization, 1990AD.
Ibn Rushd, Tahfut At-Tahafut by Dr. Mohammed Abed Al-Jabri, 1st Edition, Center for Arab Unity Studies, Beirut, 1998.
Tahafut Al-Falasifah: Imam Al-Ghazali, 6th Edition, Dar Al-Maarif, Egypt.
Hiwar Maa Sadiqi Al-Mulhed: Dr. Mustafa Mahmoud, Study, Presentation and Commentary by Dr. Mohammed Amara, Publications of the Islamic Research Complex, Al-Azhar Al-Sharif, 2017AD.
As-Sihah, Taj Al-Lughah wa Sihah Al-Arabiyyah: Abu Nasr Ismail Al-Johari, Dar El Ilm Lilmalayin.
Dawabet Al-Fikr: Mohammed Rabie Al-Jawhari, Dar Al-Iman, Cairo.
Houston, Joseph, 1994, Reported Miracles: A Critique of Hume, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Levine, Michael, 1989, Hume and the Problem of Miracles: A Solution, Dordrecht: Kluwer Publishers.
Why I Am Not a Christian and Other Essays on Religion and Related Subjects also viewed, Simon and Schuster, 1953
Popper, Karl. The Logic of Scientific Discovery. Routledge, 2002 (First published 1959).
شعبان, . (2024). Miracles: Are They a Breach of the Laws of the Universe or the Perceptions of the Mind?! A Study in Scientific Reconciliation of Extraordinary Phenomena. Al-Zahraa, 34(34), 161-262. doi: 10.21608/zjac.2024.308476.1176
MLA
محمد شعبان. "Miracles: Are They a Breach of the Laws of the Universe or the Perceptions of the Mind?! A Study in Scientific Reconciliation of Extraordinary Phenomena", Al-Zahraa, 34, 34, 2024, 161-262. doi: 10.21608/zjac.2024.308476.1176
HARVARD
شعبان, . (2024). 'Miracles: Are They a Breach of the Laws of the Universe or the Perceptions of the Mind?! A Study in Scientific Reconciliation of Extraordinary Phenomena', Al-Zahraa, 34(34), pp. 161-262. doi: 10.21608/zjac.2024.308476.1176
VANCOUVER
شعبان, . Miracles: Are They a Breach of the Laws of the Universe or the Perceptions of the Mind?! A Study in Scientific Reconciliation of Extraordinary Phenomena. Al-Zahraa, 2024; 34(34): 161-262. doi: 10.21608/zjac.2024.308476.1176