Argumentative Tools in  Islamic Media Dialogue with Deviant Muslims Abd Allah  bin Abbas's Dialogue with the Kharijites (Khawrij) as a model  ( A Pragma-Dialectic Approach

Abd Al-Nabi, Elsayed Muhammad Muhammad; Elsaeady, Doaa Abdelhakam Abdellatif

doi:10.21608/zjac.2022.273588

Argumentative Tools in Islamic Media Dialogue with Deviant Muslims Abd Allah bin Abbas's Dialogue with the Kharijites (Khawrij) as a model ( A Pragma-Dialectic Approach

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

¹ - Department of Islamic Culture, Faculty of Islamic Call, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.

² Department of Jornalism and Mass Communication, Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Girls, Cairo, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.

10.21608/zjac.2022.273588

Abstract

Argumentative Tools in Islamic Media Dialogue with Deviant Muslims
Abd Allah bin Abbas's Dialogue with the Kharijites (Khawrij) as a model
( A Pragma-Dialectic Approach)

* Elsayed Muhammad Muhammad Abd al-Nabi 1, Doaa Abd al-Hakam Abdellatif
Elsaeady2.
1- Department of Islamic Culture, Faculty of Islamic Call, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.
2-Department of Jornalism and Mass Communication, Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Girls, Cairo, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.
*Corresponding author email:
dr.doaaelsaeady@azhar.edu.eg
Abstract:
The study aims to reveal the the argumentative devices used in Islamic media dialogue with deviant Muslims. It aims to know how Ibn Abbas employs these argumentative elements in the dialogue, to reveal the implications of using these elements on Dawah (Islamic preaching), and to clarify how to apply this practical model on the media discourse and contemporary Islamic preaching .The study uses the Pragma-dialectical Approach and the deductive approach and it relies on qualitative analysis of discourse, specifically the argumerntaive analysis of discourse. The study yields a number of findings, most importantly of which is that Ibn Abbas used complementary argumentative approach at both the vertical and horizontal levels. While the argumentative conjunctive devices worked to intensify the arguments and their coherence and interconnectedness at the horizontal level, the argumentative hierarchy intensified the accumulation of arguments at the vertical level thus producing a strong tightly interwoven valid argument. The most important rhetorical strategies used include: repetition, refutation, gradualism, intimidation, and emotions stirring. One of the most important implications as regards Dawah is that the preacher should be keen on communicating his message, and working quickly to correct the wronged concepts; so that they are not exaggerated or turn into an adopted disgraceful behavior badly influencing the Muslim community. Pity and concern for the interest of the other party in dialogue and the preservation of his religion , self and his safety is required. If this is so in the dialogue with the deviants of non-Muslim, it is more appropriate and obligatory in the dialogue with the deviant Muslims

Keywords

References

Refrences

The Holy Koran.

Second: Dictionaries:
1. Ibn Manzur, Lisan Al Arab, Dar Al Maarif, Cairo, Volume 2.
2. Ar-Raghib Al-Isfahani, Mujam Mufradat Alfaz Al-Quran Al-Karim, Dar Al-Fikr, Beirut,2009.
3. Al-Mujam Al-Waseet, Arabic Language Academy, Root (ح ج ج ) 4th Edition , Ash-Shorouk Ad-Dawliyyah Bookshop, Egypt, 2003.
Third: Books, research and scientific theses:
1. Ahlam Abd Al-Aziz Al-Wasifir, Azzah Muhammad Jedoua, Al-Hijaj fi Al-Quran Al-Karim Surat Al-Hajj Namzougan, Journal of Scientific Research in Arts, p 19, part 11, 2018.
2. Tommy Issa, Al-Aliyyat Al-Hijajiyyah fi Al-Khitab Al-Qurani, Study Published and Available at https://www.asjp.cerist.dz/en/downArticle/352/8/4/39326
3. Jamila Roqab, Muhammad Haj Hani, Al-Hijaj fi Al-Khitab Al-Ilami Asaleeb Al-Iqnaa fi Barnamij "wa Ifalou Al-Khayr", Al-Alama, vol.4, p. 9, December 2019,
4. Hayat Dahman: Tajaliyyat Al-Hijaj fi Al-Quran Al-Karim Surat Yusuf Anmouzagan, MA thesis, unpublished, Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Faculty of Arts and Languages, Haj Khader University, Batna, Algeria, 2013.
5. Osman Ali Hassan: Al-Hiwar Al-Aqadi maa Al-Mukhalifeen Khasaeasuh wa Asalibuh Dirasah Quraniyyah , Al-Manbar Magazine, Sudan Scholars Association, P6, 2011.
6. Mohamed Fareh, Abd Al-Latif Hanna: Ash-Shart wa Athruh Al-Hijajji fi Al-Khitab Muqarabah Hijajiyyah Tadawuliyyah fi MUnazarah Bayn Al-Elm wa Al-Jahl Sheikh Mohamed Ad-Desi Al Jazairy, Lughat-Kalam Magazine, Relizane University , Algeria, vol.7, issue1, 2021.
7. Marwa An-Nashmi: Al-Khitab Al-Illami fi al- Khitab An-Nabawi: Dirasah fi Istratijiyyat Al-Iqnaa fi Al-Arbeen An-Nawawiyyah, Fikr wa Ibdaa, Modern Literary Publishing Association, p 103, 2016.
8. Heidi Jamal Esh-Sherbini: Benyat Al-Isifham Al-Balaghi fi Ar-Riwayah As-Siyasiyyah enda Muhammad al-Mansi Qandil, MA thesis, Department of Arabic Language, Faculty of Arts, Ain Shams University, 2017 .
9. Ahmed Helmi Abd Al-Halim : Khutbah Wasel Ibn Ataa ( 131AH), Al-Zahraa Journal Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Women in Cairo, Al-Azhar University, vol.32, p. 32, 2016April 2022, p. 1519.
10. Al-Iraqi: Takhreej Al-Ihyaa, 2/411.
11. Intisar Mahmoud Hassan, Blaghat At-Tikrar wa Al-Jinas fi Shir Abu al-Qasim al-Shabi, The Yearbook of the Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Women in Alexandria, vol.2, p. 2, p. 1079.
12. Doaa Abd Al-Hakam As-Saidi: Al-Khitab As-Sahafi li Shoyoukh Al-Azhar fi Ar-Rad ala Ash-Shubuhat Hawl Al-Islam Radd Al-Imam Al-Akbar Muhammad Sayyid Tantawi ala Pappa Al-Vatican Benedictus XVI Dirasah Tahliliyyah Osloubiyyah, Journal of Media Research, vol.50, p. 50, October 2018.
13. Abdo Ahmed Fadl Allah, Adab Al-Hiwar maa Al-Mukhalifeen min Khilal As-Sunnah An-Nabawiyyah, Maalem Ad-Dawah Al-Islamiyyah Journal, Omdurman University, p. 11, 2019, p. 230.
14. Ali Jaber Ath-Thabiti: Al-Hiwar, Al-Qiraah wa Al-Marifah Journal, Faculty of Education, Egyptian Association for Reading and Knowledge, Ain Shams University, issue132, p. 254.
15. Mohammed Khalfa Siddiq: Malameh An-Nazariyyah al-Ilamiyyah fi Al-Quran Al-Karim, Dirasat Islamiyyah Journal, p. 121
16. Muhammad Sharaf Ad-Din, Asaleeb A-Hiwar wa Al-Iqnaa fi Dawaa As-Sunnah An-Nabawiyyah min Khilal Aam Al-Wofoud. Dirasah Hadithiyyah Istiqraeiyyah, Al-Mijalah Al-Ilmiyyah, Faculty of Religion and Dawah, Zagazig, Al-Azhar University, Volume 28, issue 1, 2016.
17. Amr Ziyab Abu Haniyeh: Ar-Rawabet wa Al-Awamel Al-Hijajiyyah fi Maqamat Al-Hamazani, Arabian Journal for Scientific Research, issue 11, 2019.
18. Hautli-Janisz, Annette and others: Questions in argumentative dialogue, Journal of Pragmatics, v0l 188, 2022,p p .56-97.
.